Skip to content
AI Search Visibility

AI Overviews Traffic Is Dropping: What Still Brings Buyers to Your Site

AI Overviews Traffic Is Dropping: What Still Brings Buyers to Your Site

If your Google traffic dipped this year and nobody on your team can explain why, look at AI Overviews traffic first. AI Overviews traffic is now a line item every marketing report has to deal with: the AI-written summary at the top of Google now answers a growing share of searches, and fewer people click through to the websites underneath it.

I’m Rick Pendrick, and I run Prism PR. I have spent more than 25 years in PR, and I keep getting the same question from founders and marketing heads: “If Google answers the question itself, what still sends us buyers?” This post gives you a straight answer, with the numbers, and a short list of what I’d do about it.

One quick definition first. SEO and AEO are two sides of the same goal: showing up when people search on Google, and when they ask AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini. Everything below is about being visible in both.

How Much Is AI Overviews Traffic Loss Costing Sites?

Two independent studies put numbers on the AI Overviews traffic drop, and they point the same way.

Pew Research Center tracked the real browsing behavior of 900 U.S. adults. When a Google search showed an AI summary, users clicked a traditional result link in 8% of visits. When there was no AI summary, they clicked nearly twice as often, in 15% of visits. Clicks on a link inside the AI summary itself happened in just 1% of visits to pages that had one.

Ahrefs looked at 300,000 keywords and found that the presence of an AI Overview now correlates with a 58% lower average click-through rate for the top-ranking page. Their earlier version of the analysis, in April 2025, put the drop at 34.5%. The gap has widened.

Two cautions so you read these numbers fairly. First, these are averages. Not every search shows an AI Overview: in the Pew data, 18% of Google searches produced one. Second, correlation is not a guarantee about your site. A page that ranks first for a how-to question will feel it far more than a page that ranks for a buying-intent phrase.

If you want the wider picture of searches that end without a click, I wrote about it in zero-click search. Here I want to focus on the useful part: where the buyers go now.

Which Searches Lose the Most AI Overviews Traffic?

Not every query is equally exposed to AI Overviews traffic loss. In my experience, the pattern is simple.

Informational questions lose the most. “What is domain rating,” “how long does PR take,” “what does a PR agency do.” Google can summarize these in four lines, so the click often never happens. If your traffic plan depends on ranking for definitions, this is where you feel the cut.

Comparison and buying searches hold up better. When someone is choosing a vendor, they want to see real pages, real reviews and real proof. An AI summary is a starting point, not the end of their research.

Branded searches are the safest of all. A person typing your company name already knows you. That demand does not come from ranking tactics. It comes from people having heard of you.

That last point matters more than it first appears, and it is the thread through the rest of this post.

Where Do Buyers Come From When AI Overviews Traffic Shrinks?

Here is how I think about AI Overviews traffic. Fewer people click through from informational searches, but they still read the AI summary, and the summary still names sources and brands. Buyers are being influenced earlier, inside the answer, before they ever visit a website. So the question becomes: how do you get named, cited and trusted inside that answer?

The best evidence I know of comes from Muck Rack’s May 2026 report, What Is AI Reading?, which analyzed more than 25 million links cited by ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini. About 84% of those citations came from earned media. One note on that figure: Muck Rack’s “earned” category is broad and includes government, academic and encyclopedic sites alongside news coverage. Even so, the direction is clear. AI tools lean on sources that someone independent decided were worth writing about, not on pages brands wrote about themselves.

I walked through how Google picks what it cites in how Google AI Overviews choose their sources. The short version, for anyone worried about AI Overviews traffic, is that being mentioned by credible third parties is what gets you into the answer.

What Still Brings Buyers to Your Site Besides AI Overviews Traffic

This is the list I give clients who ask how to replace lost AI Overviews traffic. It is in order of how much I trust each one.

1. Earned media with a backlink

A backlink is a clickable link from a news story to your website, and it lifts your Google ranking. Earned coverage does two jobs now, and neither depends on AI Overviews traffic. It sends a reader straight to you, and it makes your brand a source AI tools are more likely to cite. A story in a real outlet is read by people, trusted by Google and picked up by AI answers. That is three channels from one placement.

This is the core of what we do at Prism. We are an award-winning, full-service PR agency, and also a digital PR and linkbuilding firm, so every story we earn is online and carries a backlink. Our SEO and linkbuilding service is built on exactly that.

2. Being the original source of data

Journalists link to the original number, and AI tools repeat it. When you publish data nobody else has, you become the thing others have to cite. At Prism we do this through a newsworthy, data-driven industry study: we analyze public data, find the national trend, rank every state, and pitch the results to national, trade and local media. Our 2026 industry study campaigns average 20.8 stories a month, each carrying a backlink.

Here’s a live dashboard for our client CareScout showing what we’ve secured over the last 9 months, which was a full-service campaign, including these monthly studies.

3. Branded demand

When people see your name in the news, in an AI answer and in a trade publication, some of them search for you directly. Branded searches are the AI Overviews traffic problem you do not have, the clicks AI Overviews cannot take away, because the searcher already chose you. It is also the hardest thing to fake, which is why PR is a better source of it than a content calendar alone.

4. Pages built for buying intent

Stop measuring every page by traffic. A pricing page, a case study or a comparison page may get a fraction of the visits a blog post does, but it converts. Review your case studies and service pages and make sure they are the strongest pages on your site. Visitors who do click through from an AI summary tend to be further along in the decision.

5. Owned channels that don’t depend on Google

An email list, a LinkedIn following and a podcast appearance all send buyers without going through a search box. They are slower to build, and they make you less dependent on any one algorithm.

What I Would Change in Your Plan This Quarter

If I were advising you today, I’d make four changes.

Audit your top pages by purpose. Split them into “informational” and “buying.” Expect the informational group to lose AI Overviews traffic and stop treating that decline as a failure of effort.

Move budget toward earned coverage. Paid placements do not carry the same weight, and I never recommend them. Real stories in real outlets are what pull you into AI answers and send readers. I explain the difference in earned media vs paid media.

Pitch with data. A reporter is far more likely to open a pitch that has a number in it. If you want the mechanics, read how to pitch a journalist.

Measure visibility, not only AI Overviews traffic. Track whether your brand is named when you ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Google the questions your buyers ask. Track branded search volume. Keep traffic on the dashboard, but stop treating it as the only score.

For the full picture of how SEO, AEO and generative engine optimization fit together, start with our SEO, AEO and GEO page.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much do AI Overviews reduce traffic?

It depends on the study and the query. Pew Research found users clicked a result link in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, versus 15% when it did not. Ahrefs found the top-ranking page’s click-through rate was about 58% lower when an AI Overview was present.

Does AI Overviews traffic loss affect every Google search?

No. In Pew’s data, 18% of Google searches in the study produced an AI summary. Informational questions are the most likely to trigger one, and buying-intent and branded searches are less exposed.

Is SEO still worth it if AI Overviews traffic keeps falling?

Yes, but the job has changed. Ranking still matters, and so does being named and cited inside AI answers. SEO and AEO now work together, and both reward credible third-party coverage and backlinks from real news outlets.

What kind of content do AI tools cite most?

Muck Rack’s May 2026 analysis of more than 25 million AI-cited links found about 84% came from earned media, a category that includes news coverage as well as government, academic and encyclopedic sites.

How do I get my brand cited in AI answers?

Get written about by credible, independent sources. That means media relations, original data that journalists want to cite, and backlinks from real outlets. It is slower than publishing blog posts, and it is the thing that holds up.

The Bottom Line on AI Overviews Traffic

AI Overviews traffic losses are real: AI Overviews are cutting clicks on informational searches, and the data is consistent about it. What they have not cut is trust. Buyers still choose companies they have seen mentioned by someone credible, and AI tools still pull from those same credible sources. Earn the coverage, and you show up in the answer, in the ranking and in the searches for your name.

If you want help replacing lost AI Overviews traffic with coverage that lasts, get in touch with us and we’ll walk you through what it would look like for your company.

Keep Reading

Related Posts

Get Started

Want Coverage Like This for Your Brand?

Tell us what you want to be known for. We will show you how earned media gets you there.